Murphy’s other sin was using “dog whistles such as ‘traditional marriage’ in his brief.” Obergefell doesn’t bother to explain what improper signal “traditional marriage” sends. And because it wasn’t mandated by the constitution, it wasn’t unconstitutional for the state not to recognize it. In short, Obergefell’s marriage was neither mandated nor prohibited by the constitution. If the appropriate legislative body had approved of same sex marriage, instead of barring it as Ohio did, the marriage would not have been problematic. This doesn’t mean that same sex marriage is unconstitutional. His contention was that the constitution creates no right to same sex marriage. The op-ed displays ignorance and arrogance in equal measure.Īccording to Obergefell, Murphy “argued that my marriage in unconstitutional.” Murphy made no such argument. The Washington Post has published an op-ed by Obergefell blasting Murphy and criticizing Portman for supporting him. Rob Portman, one of Murphy’s home state Senators, backs the nomination, even though Portman supports same sex marriage. President Trump has nominated Murphy for the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals. Eric Murphy is a lawyer who, in his capacity as Solicitor General of Ohio, argued against inventing such a right. Jim Obergefell is the successful plaintiff in the case where the Supreme Court invented a constitutional right to same sex marriage.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |